Released October 2010.
For their 25th season, current NLC singers and alumni have compiled this two-disc collection of favorite works from the past years. These works were taken from 24 of the choir's recordings, beginning with tracks conducted by founder Larry Fleming, and ending with selections from Hymns We Love to Sing, Vol II, which was recorded live this past spring.
| Disc / Track | Title | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 / 1 | Sing and Ponder | |
| 1 / 2 | Donde Hay | |
| 1 / 3 | Holy Spirit | |
| 1 / 4 | Psallite | |
| Listen | 1 / 5 | Infant Holy, Infant Lowly |
| Listen | 1 / 6 | Away in a Manger |
| Listen | 1 / 7 | There Is No Rose |
| Listen | 1 / 8 | The Glory of the Father |
| Listen | 1 / 9 | I Heard a Great Voice |
| Listen | 1 / 10 | Out of the Orient Crystal Skies |
| Listen | 1 / 11 | Wondrous Birth |
| Listen | 1 / 12 | O Little Town of Bethlehem |
| Listen | 1 / 13 | Who Shall Separate Us |
| Listen | 1 / 14 | Come, Holy Ghost |
| Listen | 1 / 15 | Nunc Dimittis |
| Listen | 1 / 16 | O Light Everlasting |
| Listen | 1 / 17 | A Christmas Carol |
| Listen | 1 / 18 | Now All Poor and Humble |
| Listen | 1 / 19 | Prayer to Jesus |
| Listen | 1 / 20 | I Will Sing to the Lord |
| Listen | 1 / 21 | My Friend Had a Vineyard |
| Listen | 1 / 22 | Inscription from the Catacombs |
| Listen | 1 / 23 | My Lord, What a Mornin' |
| Listen | 1 / 24 | There is a Balm in Gilead |
| Listen | 1 / 25 | My Soul - Jesus Loves Me |
| Listen | 1 / 26 | In the Beginning was the Word |
| Listen | 1 / 27 | Ubi Caritas |
| Listen | 1 / 28 | Blessed Are They |
| Listen | 1 / 29 | Rise Up, My Love, My Fair One |
| Listen | 1 / 30 | Ah, Holy Jesus |
| Listen | 1 / 31 | Sweet Was the Song |
| Listen | 2 / 1 | How Great are Thy Wonders (We Sing with Joy) |
| Listen | 2 / 2 | Pilgrim's Chorus |
| Listen | 2 / 3 | For God Commanded Angels |
| Listen | 2 / 4 | Creation Suite |
| Listen | 2 / 5 | I Got Shoes |
| Listen | 2 / 6 | Lord God, You Have Called Your Servants |
| Listen | 2 / 7 | Tell 'em I'm Gone |
| Listen | 2 / 8 | Hear Us, O Father |
| Listen | 2 / 9 | What Child |
| Listen | 2 / 10 | Lo, How a Rose |
| Listen | 2 / 11 | Love Divine, All Loves Excelling |
| Listen | 2 / 12 | I Sat Down Under His Shadow |
| Listen | 2 / 13 | Lamb of God |
| Listen | 2 / 14 | Seigneur, je vois en prie |
| Listen | 2 / 15 | O Sacrum conc vivium |
| Listen | 2 / 16 | Lord Jesus Think About Me |
| Listen | 2 / 17 | Go and Tell John |
| Listen | 2 / 18 | Everytime I Think About Jesus |
| Listen | 2 / 19 | Angel Proclamation |
| Listen | 2 / 20 | Angel Song II |
| Listen | 2 / 21 | O Nata Lux (from Lux Aeterna) |
| Listen | 2 / 22 | Now All the Woods are Sleeping |
| Listen | 2 / 23 | Down In the River to Pray |
| Listen | 2 / 24 | Standin' In the Need of Prayer |
| Listen | 2 / 25 | The Lord Bless You and Keep You |